Janelle's Survivor: All-Stars

Janelle's Survivor - Melanesia - All-Stars
Season 8
Genre Reality competition
Winner Amanda P. (losangelesgirl) (5-2-0)
No. of episodes 14
No. of days 15
No. of castaways 18
Tribes      Flores
Filming Location EfateShefa Province,
Season Run July 20, 2013 –
August 4, 2013
Opening Sequence
Previous season Survivor: Libya
Next season Survivor: Guadeloupe

Survivor: Melanesia - All-Stars (more commonly known as Survivor: All-Stars) is the eighth season of Janelle's Survivor Series, which began on July 20, 2013.

The season featured eighteen returning contestants, dubbed as "All-Stars", marking this as the first season to feature an all-returning cast. The cast consisted of three returnees from Maldives, Aruba, Germany and Libya each, and two returnees from Cayman Islands, Tanzania and New Zealand each.

For the first time since Survivor: New Zealand, there were three tribes rather than the usual two. Each tribe consisted of six castaways considered as the "Best of the Best" from their respective seasons. There was Flores, wearing yellow buffs, and Makira, wearing green buffs, both named after islands in the Melanesian sub-region, and Huli, wearing red buffs, named after a group of indigenous people in Papua New Guinea, in Melanesia. On Day 5, the three tribes become two, Flores and Huli, during a tribe switch.

Amanda P. was named the Sole Survivor in the season finale on August 4, 2013, defeating runners-up Oliver L. and Joe K. in a 5-2-0 vote.


Contestant Original Tribe Switched Tribe Merged Tribe Voted Out Total Votes
Andrea Andrea I.
17, Orange
Huli 1st Voted Out
Day 1
Alex G. Alex G.
13, Red
Flores 2nd Voted Out
Day 1
Rich M Rich M.
17, Light Green
Makira 3rd Voted Out
Day 2
Logan E Logan E.
16, White
Flores 4th Voted Out
Day 3
Stephen J Stephen J.
15, Orange
Huli 5th Voted Out
Day 4
Natasha B. Natasha B.
19, Light Green
Makira 6th Voted Out
Day 5
Ethan O. Ethan O.
16, Silver
Cayman Islands
Huli Huli 7th Voted Out
Day 6
Conor P. Conor P.
16, Orange
Huli Huli 8th Voted Out
Day 7
Cory L. Cory L.
14, Black
Cayman Islands
Flores Flores Mahulores 9th Voted Out
1st Jury Member
Day 8
Jeremy B Jeremy B.
15, Orange
Huli Flores 10th Voted Out
2nd Jury Member
Day 9
Cole C Cole C.
21, Light Green
Makira Flores 11th Voted Out
3rd Jury Member
Day 10
Joe Joe H.
17, Sky Blue
Flores Flores 12th Voted Out
4th Jury Member
Day 11
Ryan A Ryan A.
15, Blue
New Zealand
Huli Flores 13th Voted Out
5th Jury Member
Day 12
15, Brown
Flores Huli 14th Voted Out
6th Jury Member
Day 13
Brendon Brendon L.
17, Brown
Makira Huli 15th Voted Out
7th Jury Member
Day 14
Joe K Joe K.
18, Light Green
New Zealand
Makira Huli 2nd Runner-up 3
Oliver L. Oliver L.
18, Red
Makira Flores Runner-up 0
Amanda P Amanda P.
15, Black
Flores Huli Sole Survivor 6

The Total Votes is the number of votes a castaway received during Tribal Councils where the castaway was eligible to be voted out of the game, excluding tiebreakers. It does not include the votes received during the final Tribal Council.

The GameEdit

Episode title Immunity Eliminated Vote Voted Out
"Those Damn Bananas Screwed Me Last Time" Makira Andrea 5-1 1st Voted Out
Day 1
Alex 5-1 2nd Voted Out
Day 1
"There Is Only One Joe In This Henhouse!" Huli Rich 5-1 3rd Voted Out
Day 2
"Sue Me Please" Huli Logan 3-2 4th Voted Out
Day 3
"A Series of Unfortunate Events" Flores Stephen 3-2 5th Voted Out
Day 4
"He's Honestly a Tard" Huli Natasha 4-1 6th Voted Out
Day 5
"They Always Find Ways" Flores Ethan 2-2-2
7th Voted Out
Day 6
"Having To Hustle Very Hard" Flores Conor 4-1 8th Voted Out
Day 7
"You Gotta Be Prepared To Go Big or Go Home" Amanda Cory 5-3-2 9th Voted Out
Day 8
"Can't Wait For This Blindside" Cole Jeremy 6-4 10th Voted Out
Day 9
"I Have Been Lying To You The Whole Season" Joe H. Cole 4-2-2 11th Voted Out
Day 10
"True To Myself" Oliver Joe H. 5-2 12th Voted Out
Day 11
"I Never Feel Safe In This Game" Oliver Ryan 3-2-1 13th Voted Out
Day 12
"There's a Fine Line Between Bold and Stupid" Oliver JG 3-1-1 14th Voted Out
Day 13
"My Flame Has Finally Been Snuffed" Oliver Brendon 3-1 15th Voted Out
Day 14
Jury vote Joe K. 5-2-0 Third Place
Oliver Runner-up
Amanda Sole Survivor

In the case of multiple tribes or castaways who win immunity, they are listed in order of finish, or alphabetically where it was a team effort; where one castaway won and invited others, the invitees are in brackets.

Episode 1: "Those Damn Bananas Screwed Me Last Time"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: Pass The Torch – Players had to pass a torch to their fellow tribemates, and the first tribe to have passed the torch around the whole tribe and successfully light it on the fire win.

Episode 2: "There is Only One Joe in This Henhouse!"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: Chum Bucket – Fishes popped up at random intervals during the day. When a fish popped up, the first contestant to spear the fish scored a point for their tribe.

Episode 3: "Sue Me Please"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: Crack The Code – The contestants had to find a scrambled Survivor-related word by cracking a code, then unscramble the word they found.

Episode 4: "A Series of Unfortunate Events"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: Turf Wars – There were eight territories which closed at random intervals during the challenge. Whichever tribe was the last to claim the territory won a certain amount of points. The tribes with the most points won immunity.

Episode 5: "He's Honestly a Tard"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: Capture The Flag – The contestants were presented with a flag, and the first contestant to correctly guess what country the flag belonged to, won a point for their tribe.

Episode 6: "They Always Find Ways"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: Blog Wars – The tribes' blog with the most votes in a certain time limit won the immunity challenge.

Episode 7: "Having To Hustle Very Hard"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: Picture This – The contestants were given a drawing of a famous celebrity. In order to gain a point towards immunity, they had to correctly guess the celebrity in the picture.

Episode 8: "You Gotta Be Prepared To Go Big or Go Home"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: None – Survivor Auction. - The players began with 500 Survivor Bucks, and they had to bid on several rewards (some covered, some not covered) and the highest bidder attained the reward.

Episode 9: "Can't Wait For This Blindside"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: Survivor Spelling Bee – Contestants had to search through a patch of mud to find five bags of random letters, and they had to form the longest word possible using the letters inside the bag. Whoever managed to spell the longest word won immunity.

Episode 10: "I Have Been Lying To You The Whole Season"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: Bridge It – The final eight had to participate in a challenge where they had to compete in heats. The first player to reach the finish line won immunity. 

Episode 11: "True To Myself"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: Photographic Memory – The contestants were presented with random objects throughout the game, unaware of there importance in the game. At this immunity challenge, they were asked questions about the random appearances of these objects, if they were correct, they scored a point towards immunity. The contestant with the most points won immunity.

Episode 12: "I Never Feel Safe In This Game"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: Tanks for the Memories – Contestants had to submit the highest score in the game Tankopter. The person with the highest submittted score won immunity.

Episode 13: "There's a Fine Line Between Bold and Stupid"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: Karma Seeker – The players were given a number of Karma, and in order to win a point they had to find a user with or near to this amount of Karma and have the closest answer.

Episode 14: "My Flame Has Finally Been Snuffed"Edit

  • Immunity Challenge: The Ball Drop – The final four had to balance a small metal ball on a wooden cylinder, while holding the center cylinder in place with two wooden handles. At random times, new pieces of the wooden rod were added, making it harder to balance the ball on the center cylinder. Whoever managed to balance their ball the longest won immunity.

Voting historyEdit

Original Tribes Switched Tribes Merged Tribe
Episode #: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Eliminated: Andrea
5/6 votes
5/6 votes
5/6 votes
3/5 votes
3/5 votes
4/5 votes
Tie Ethan
3/3 votes
4/5 votes
5/10 votes
6/10 votes
4/8 votes
Joe H.
5/7 votes
3/6 votes
3/5 votes
3/4 votes
Voter Vote
Amanda Alex Logan Conor Ethan Conor Cory Jeremy Cole Joe H. Brendon Brendon Brendon
Oliver Rich Natasha JG Jeremy Cole Joe H. Ryan JG Brendon
Joe K. Rich Natasha Ethan Ethan Conor Cory Jeremy Cole Joe H. Ryan JG Brendon
Brendon Rich Natasha Ethan Tied1 Conor Cory2 Jeremy2 JG Joe H. Ryan JG Amanda
JG Alex Logan Conor Ethan Conor Cole Brendon Cole Joe H. Brendon Joe K.
Ryan Andrea Stephen JG Brendon Amanda Amanda Amanda
Joe H. Alex Cory None Brendon Amanda Amanda
Cole Rich Natasha JG Jeremy JG
Jeremy Andrea Ethan Cory Brendon
Cory Alex Logan Cole
Conor Andrea Stephen Brendon Tied1 Joe K.
Ethan Andrea Stephen Brendon Tied1
Natasha Rich Joe
Stephen Andrea Ethan
Logan Alex Cory
Rich Cole
Alex Logan
Andrea Jeremy
Jury vote
Finalist: Joe
0/7 votes
2/7 votes
5/7 votes
Voter Vote
Brendon Oliver
JG Amanda
Ryan Amanda
Joe Amanda
Cole Oliver
Jeremy Amanda
Cory Amanda


  • This was the first season to have an all-returning cast.
    • Amanda P, Oliver L, Joe K, and Ryan A. are the only returning players to place higher then they did in their original season.
  • Survivor: All-Stars was originally going to be the sixth season of Janelle's Survivor, however just over a week before broadcast the season was moved back to the eighth season and replaced with Survivor: Germany.
  • This was the first season since Survivor: Tanzania to feature a Survivor Auction.

Returning castawaysEdit

So far, no castaways from Survivor: All-Stars have returned for any other season.


Janelle's Survivor Series
Hall of FameTribesContestantsAwards and RecordsTwistsProduction Team
Maldives Cayman Islands
Alexandra A.Austin B.Cole Y.Cory L.Eddie F.Ethan O.George I.Jake A.
Matt D.Mearl L.Nick L.Oakley F.Ryder B.Sam B.Sam S.Sean R.
Aimee • AJ • Alan • Andrea • Brendon • Christian • Dan • Em
Joe • Josh • Maks • Michael • Missy • Ranz • Thomas • Ty
Alexandra • Austin • Cole • Cory • Eddie • Ethan • George • Jake
Matt • Mearl • Nick • Oakley • Ryder • Sam B. • Sam S. • Sean
Tanzania New Zealand
Acacia C.Alex G.Alicia N.Andrew M.Brian C.Bubba D.Cedric T.Chris B.Christian N.
DJ C.Martin H.Mona M.Natasha B.Sean C.Sedona D.Snow G.Sterling W.Will C.
AJBrian C.Dono REric MJack JJacob KJake A.Jeremy LJoe K
Katherine AKenny FKiko RLeah LLynette JRonald CRyan ASeth JVictor B
Acacia • Alex • Alicia • Andrew • Brian • Bubba • Cedric • Chris • Christian
DJ • Martin • Mona • Natasha • Sean • Sedona • Snow • Sterling • Will
AJ • Brian • Dono • Eric • Jack • Jacob • Jake • Jeremy • Joe
Katherine • Kenny • Kiko • Leah • Lynette • Ronald • Ryan • Seth • Victor
Aruba Germany
Blake L.Conor P.Fred N.Jake B.Jake H.James D.Jeff T.JG Z.
Joshua R.LeQuisha L.Link M.Oliver L.Rafael A.Sandra J.Shawn D.Snow F.
Adam DAlex SAvatar ABrad BCole CFelix LKyle KLogan E
Matthew HMikayla LOliver ZSam B.Sedona D.Simon PStephen JZach L
Blake • Conor • Fred • Jake B. • Jake H. • James • Jeff • JG
Joshua • LeQuisha • Link • Oliver • Rafael • Sandra • Shawn • Snow
Adam • Alex • Avatar • Brad • Cole • Felix • Kyle • Logan
Matthew • Mikayla • Oliver • Sam • Sedona • Simon • Stephen • Zach
Libya All-Stars
Amanda PDan KDanielle MEoin QHilary CJarrod LJeremy BJohn Z
Luis LMiles BNeil RRay LRich MRyan PSam CTy M
Alex G.Amanda PAndreaBrendonCole CConor P.Cory L.Ethan O.Jeremy B
JG Z.JoeJoe KLogan ENatasha B.Oliver L.Rich MRyan AStephen J
Amanda • Dan • Danielle • Eoin • Hillary • Jarrod • Jeremy • John
Luis • Miles • Neil • Ray • Rich • Ryan • Sam • Ty
Alex • Amanda • Andrea • Brendon • Cole • Conor • Cory • Ethan • Jeremy
JG • Joe K. • Joe H. • Logan • Natasha • Oliver • Rich • Ryan • Stephen
Guadeloupe El Salvador
Ali • Boston • Bryce • Chloe • Chris • Jack • Jake • Lauren
Logan • Nick • Peyton • Ryan • Samuel • Stephen • Tanqueray • Tyler
Alexandra • Austin • Bobby • Boston • Cameron • Chris • Jake • JoJo
Kamani • Paul • Rhys • Riley • Steve • Shawn • Ty • Zachary
Adam D. • Adam O. • Ali • Andie • Cody • Dan • Davey • Dexter • Ismail
Jacob • Jade • Joey • Lincoln • Lukas • Mike • Natalie • Sim • Tim